The Reluctant Security Guard Essay - 875 Words

The Reluctant Security Guard Companies in today’s society are often required to abide by an abundant amount of rules and regulations imposed upon them which stem from government and law enforcement authority. In analyzing the Case of â€Å"The Reluctant Security Guard† we will examine the decision making process which led to David Tuff effectively ‘whistle blowing’ for what he felt was the right thing to do. The policy that was in place for David Tuff was ultimately an oath he subscribed to when he became a security guard, as well as his integrity of being a former U.S. Marine. He was required to abide by the Security Officer’s Manual, which included obeying the rules and regulations of the Superintendent of Police. There is no ambiguity†¦show more content†¦Are the reasons for whistle blowing in line with reasons everyone can act upon in principle alone? Tuff met with two other security guards regarding the overall issues, they concurred with him that they too had grievances against the company policies. This act promotes the concept of universalizability, and how it can be applied to the moral dilemma that Tuff faced. He now had people on his side, this allowed him to gain emotional momentum which led him to speaking to the press shortly after he met with his co-workers. As far as reversibility applies to this examination, we could deduce that Tuff felt that his action s would be just in that it would apply to him if the table was turned and he was an innocent bystander waiting to bit hit by a drunk driver. Reversibility leads us to challenge the amount of moral worth in the sense of duty that Tuff had to his oath, and to society. There is no doubt Tuff felt that his duties as a U.S. Marine Corps veteran and a sworn in security guard outweighed the conduct and vision of the policy makers at the Blue Mountain Company. An argument can be made that whistle blowing should only be warranted when there is a group or a majority that feels something should be brought to the attention of an outside authority if deemed so. As discussed in the study the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) determined that since his actions were not a concerted effort among him and his colleagues, theShow MoreRelatedThe Reluctant Security Guard800 Words   |  3 PagesThe Reluctant Security Guard 1. Relevant Facts 1.1. David Tuff was a security guard at the Blue Mountain Company in Minneapolis, Minnesota. 1.2 As part of his job training, it was necessary for him to get a security guard license, requiring him to obey the Security Officer’s Manual, which included the following statement: â€Å"If a serious accident or illegal behavior should occur on the premises of the licensee, it shall be the responsibility of the licensee to notify the appropriate police departmentRead MoreThe Reluctant Security Guard1593 Words   |  7 PagesDavid Tuff is a security guard of Blue Mountain which is a company that manages and operates retail shopping malls. As a security guard he is required by law to report to the police all serious accidents and crimes, including felonies, occurring within the premises in which he is working. However, fourteen months after his date of employment Blue Mountain created a new company policy requiring the security guards to escort intoxicated persons, including drunk drivers, from the parking lots ontoRead MoreCriminal Acts683 Words   |  3 PagesCriminal Acts Chinook Middle School security guard who was a former cop was charged with misdemeanor assault following allegations that on February 1, 2011, he choked a 14-year-old student until his face turned blue. Greg F. Seth was a former Seattle police officer who worked for the district for 15 years. After Seth had filed a complaint that the boy pushed past him the boy was immediately arrested (Pulkkinen, 2011). However, two months elapsed before the district filed a formal police reportRead MoreDefinition Of Explicit Cost Of The Marriott s Reputation969 Words   |  4 Pagespreviously could not afford housing now will be able to. Those who lose from rent-controlled housing will be landlords. Landlords will now have less incentives to fixing up housing or maintaining the upkeep of their properties. Landlords will also be reluctant to continue to purchase properties for rent if their profits will be minimized by rent-control. d) There is no incentive now for landlords to continue to maintain their properties or to fix problems that arise due to the shortage that the rent-controlledRead MoreCounterfeit Merchandise Impact The U.s. Economy900 Words   |  4 Pagesideas are less reluctant to invent. What safety and health concerns are posed by counterfeit products? Stolen Intellectual Property links to safety issues with medicines. The products do not have the same characteristics reducing the quality of the treatment placing patient s lives at risk. If electronic products do not perform properly, the product may malfunction causing an accident leading to a serious injury or death. How does IP theft pose an existential threat to national security? CounterfeitRead MoreThe Necessary Nature Of Future Firms1399 Words   |  6 Pagesdemise or a loss of market share. A review of technological advances and transformative concepts in the security industry support the notion that organizational learning and knowledge acquisition are critical for security practitioners to be competitive and relevant in the future. To elucidate on the point of being proactive, a literary review has been conduct on Digitization in the security industry, GPS technology, Cloud Base Services and Apps, Power over the Ethernet, Digital Cameras and networkRead MoreBuilding Partnerships in Professional and Military Education Schools1462 Words   |  6 PagesOn Sep 11, 2001, al Qaeda threatened the United States (U.S.) national security, and we are still combating terrorism. Since that time, al Qaeda and other extremist groups have also been endangering some of the U.S. allies. Realizing the magnitude of this international fight, the U.S. needs help from i ts partners to counter violence worldwide. National Strategic Guidance The National Security Strategy (NSS), the National Defense Strategy (NDS), and the National Military Strategy (NMS) directivesRead MoreAnalysis Of The Documentary The Untouchables847 Words   |  4 Pagesfailing of multiple mortgage backed securities that were fraudulently cobbled together with very lax oversight, were never criminally indicted for their actions. Part of the explanation from the Justice Department was that they were afraid that aggressively pursuing the presidents and vice-presidents of the banks involved in the fraudulent mortgage backed securities would make the banking industry even more unstable. This was something that they were very reluctant to risk, since so many banks wereRead MoreThe Basic Pistol Qualification Course1598 Words   |  7 Pagesrepeated if members allow their qualification to lapse. Qualifying on the basic pistol course repeatedly is a time consuming and costly evolution. The basic pistol qualification should be removed from the firearm s re-qualification standard. 2. Coast Guard policy currently requires that any pistol qualified members who have allowed their qualification to lapse, or failed to re-qualify on Practical Pistol Course (PPC), must re-qualify on the basic pistol course before attempting to qualify on the PPCRead More802.11ac and 802.11ad996 Words   |  4 Pagessymbol of the Old Regime, and its fall clearly demonstrated the rapily growing popular defiance. The event also destroyed Louis courage and his municipal Parisian government, which was replaced by a middle-class council, with its own national guard. Meanwhile, other urban uprisings and peasant violence in the country consolidated the Assembys position. Another unique aspect of the summer upheaval was the aggressive roles played by women. In the cahiers they had presented demands for legal